The best grilled cheese ever has a crispy-crunchy exterior, a melty cheddar interior, and the cheese pull that will blow your mind. Choose a hearty loaf of bread, butter it, and shred your favorite cheddar.
A grilled cheese is only as good as the cheese used in it, so be sure to use melty varieties like American, cheddar, pepper jack, havarti, gruyere, and Monterey Jack. Shredded cheese will melt more quickly than a slice and create a better cheese pull for the best results, so be sure to shred the cheese yourself rather than purchasing pre-shredded varieties, which have additives to keep them from melting as quickly.
Mayonnaise and butter both work great for getting an extra crispy exterior, but mayonnaise adds an extra layer of creaminess and saltiness. A tip we love is to use salted butter for your grilled cheese if you don’t want to use mayonnaise. Our classic grilled cheese keeps the tradition of using softened butter to coat the outside of the sandwich.
The best thing about a grilled cheese is that you can add anything to it, including bacon or ham, apples and jam with brie for a sweeter grilled cheese, or an antipasto grilled cheese for a more distinctive flavor.
We prefer a slice of bread that isn’t too thick so that the whole thing feels crispy. Really any bread works well in a grilled cheese. We love a slice of sourdough, white bread, and even brioche.
Editor’s Note: On April 22, 2022, the recipe’s introduction was updated to include more details about the dish. Continue Reading Below to Learn How to Make It!
HOW TO MAKE A PERFECT GRILLED CHEESE SANDWICH…KINDA | Jennifer Fix
Best Grilled Cheese 🔗
Simple is best when it comes to classics like a grilled cheese sandwich! All you need is bread, butter, and lots of cheese for this version.
- 5 tbsp. butter, softened, divided
- 4 slices sourdough bread
- 2 c. shredded cheddar
- Spread 1 tablespoon butter on one side of each slice of bread. With butter side down, top each slice of bread with about ½ cup cheddar.
- In a skillet over medium heat, melt 1 tablespoon butter. Add two slices of bread, butter side down. Cook until bread is golden and cheese is starting to melt, about 2 minutes. Flip one piece of bread on top of the other and continue to cook until cheese is melty, about 30 seconds more.
- Repeat for the second sandwich, wiping skillet clean if necessary.
What is the best cheese for grilled cheese?
American cheese, Cheddar cheese, Brie, Monterey Jack cheese, Pepper Jack cheese, Gouda, Havarti, and Fontina are some of the cheeses I choose to use because the differences between yellow and white Cheddar are not very great.
Is butter or mayo better for grilled cheese?
The exterior of grilled cheese made with mayo rather than butter has a rich, golden color, and some people even remark that it tastes better.
What should I add to grilled cheese?
Instructions Butter each slice of bread on both sides…. Grill until golden. Flip the slice and spread the cheese on the hot bread…. Cover the bread with another slice, hotter side facing up, and grill until golden and the cheese starts to melt. On a low to medium heat.